| Year | Team Champion | Summary |
| 1984 | Allen | Allen had 8 finalists in winning the 1st ASD tournament in crosstown rival Dieruff's gym. Emmaus & Salisbury each had 3 champs. |
| 1985 | Allen | Allen repeated by edging Dieruff 137-134 with four champs to the Huskies' two. |
| 1986 | Allen | Allen cruised to a 3rd straight title with 6 champions. |
| 1987 | Dieruff | Mel Riddick's Huskies had 3 champs to win the team title. At 105, Whitehall freshman Doug Bonshak defeated Allen sophomore Jason Wagner 9-7. Salisbury's Lee Todora won his 3rd ASD title and his 100th career bout. |
| 1988 | Allen | Allen, Central Catholic and Whitehall all had 3 champs each, but it was the Canaries who claimed the team title. |
| 1989 | Catasauqua | Catty raced out to an early lead and placed 9 wrestlers to outdistance Allen & Central Catholic, who each had 4 champs. |
| 1990 | Catasauqua | The Rough Riders repeated by crowning 4 champions, and Whitehall's Doug Bonshak won his 4th title. |
| 1991 | Allen | 4-time champ Dan Wagner led Allen's 6 finalists as they topped Catasauqua who crowned an impressive 5 champions. |
| 1992 | Dieruff | The Huskies had 4 champs including OW Billy Burch. |
| 1993 | Emmaus | Coach Tom Schleicher's Hornets had 4 champs to take their 1st time title in the 10th annual contest. Dieruff was 2nd, and Salisbury's Brian Nesfeder won his 3rd title. |
| 1994 | Emmaus | Emmaus repeated as team champ as OW Toby Kratzer was 1 of 3 individual titlists. Central Catholic was 2nd. |
| 1995 | Emmaus | Emmaus made it the trifecta in the final ASD tourney nipping Pleasant Valley by 1 point. |